New York Pizza Express

4.6 ( 344 reviews )
Checking... 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM See Hours
$1–10
4520 Potter Rd, Stallings, NC 28104, United States
+1 704-821-2020

New York Pizza Express, located at 4520 Potter Rd in Stallings, NC, has quickly become a local favorite for pizza enthusiasts. With a menu that offers a variety of options, customers rave about the freshness of the ingredients and the welcoming atmosphere provided by the friendly staff.

Reviews consistently highlight the sausage and mushroom pizza, as well as the classic plain cheese, as must-tries. One enthusiastic patron, Eric, emphasizes the importance of picking up your order to ensure optimal temperature and freshness. American supported this sentiment, praising the non-greasy, perfectly cooked slices laden with ample toppings, including unique additions like green olives.

Moreover, the restaurant garners acclaim for its quick delivery and value, with T Woods noting the speedy service without compromising quality. Lyn's experience reflects the establishment's family-friendly vibe, mentioning how her family has returned multiple times within a week due to their delightful options, including notable spaghetti and meatballs.

Overall, New York Pizza Express is not just about pizza; it’s about community and quality. For anyone seeking a delightful meal that echoes the true essence of New York-style pizza, this establishment is undoubtedly a gem worth exploring.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • No wheelchair-accessible car park
    • No wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
  • Popular for
    • Popular for lunch
    • Popular for dinner
  • Offerings
    • Serves late-night food
    • Has private dining room
    • Quick bite
    • Serves vegetarian dishes
  • Dining options
    • Serves lunch
    • Serves dinner
    • Has catering
    • Has counter service
    • Serves dessert
  • Amenities
    • No toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
    • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Planning
    • Doesn't accept reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • Has kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For New York Pizza Express

ericb399
Jun 27,2025
We love New York Pizza Express! our favorite is the sausage and mushroom and the plain cheese. I recommend that you get off the couch and go pick it up at their location. Yes, they do deliver, but why trust the temperature of your pizza to traffic conditions? The staff is friendly, and the ingredients are fresh.
American Eitel
May 25,2025
Excellent Pizza. Call in and pick it up. Don't miss out on this pizza that is cooked to perfection and not greasy. Plenty of toppings for the pizzas including green olives. Give New York Pizza Express a try for your next pizza order.
DJ Hart
May 17,2025
Not only are these folks super friendly and casual, their pizza has a zing to it that I can't identify... But it's delicious! And it's more than just pizza. You should definitely check out their menu on your next pizza night.
T Woods
May 8,2025
Had 2 large pizzas delivered. The pizza was perfect, not greasy, nice crust and toppings. Delivered fast.
Lyn
May 8,2025
This is what you call pizza! Amazing customer service and very nice family. Me and my family moved close and we’ve been here 2x in one week. My sister 2x this week as well. Delicious pizza and the spaghetti and meatballs are great. This place is a Gem!!!!! No where can I order (4) 10” personal pizzas with 5 drinks and spaghetti and meatballs for 33! Lunch specials are really specials!
Chessie Domrongchai
Apr 22,2025
Honestly the best pizza around. Crunchy crust, non-greasy (idk how they manage that but it’s amazing), quick, and delicious. The buffalo chicken is our favorite and by far the best buffalo chicken pizza we’ve had! Don’t judge a book by its cover, this place is awesome.
Mike Cavanaugh
Mar 24,2025
Reminds me of pizzerias from back in NJ. No frills, if you're looking for fad toppings (figs, caviar, buffalo chicken, cheese steak....ECT) this isn't the place for you (although they do have a Hawaiian pie). But if you're in the mood for traditional NY style pies, give them a shot, you won't be disappointed. We got a plain pie and a white w/spinach, both delicious, we'll definitely be back.
Jose Green
Mar 19,2025
Best Pizza in Matthew’s/Stallings & Indian Trail Pure & Simple!!! Never disappointed in 10 years!!! Love their stromboli!!! New York Pizza Express is supreme.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Freshii south common
(105 review)
Freshii south common
  • 2209 98 St NW, Edmonton, AB T6N 1K7, Canada
health food restaurant
+1 587-782-9443
Kiyo Café
(352 review)
Kiyo Café
  • C. de Manuel Bravo 312, RUTA INDEPENDENCIA, Centro, 68000 Oaxaca de Juárez, Oax., Mexico
Cafeteria
Cinco De Mayo
(623 review)
Cinco De Mayo
  • 1039 West Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 609-399-0199
Noffy's Sandwich Shop & Pub
(468 review)
Noffy's Sandwich Shop & Pub
  • 122 N Main St, McPherson, KS 67460, United States
restaurant
+1 620-242-1209
Speck's Deli & Gourmet Pizza
(258 review)
Speck's Deli & Gourmet Pizza
  • 12144 William Penn Hwy, Huntingdon, PA 16652, United States
italian restaurant
+1 814-641-9466
Milwaukee Burger Company - Wausau
(2777 review)
Milwaukee Burger Company - Wausau
  • 2200 Stewart Ave, Wausau, WI 54401, United States
Restaurant
+1 715-298-9371
Fifi's on the Beach Seafood Restaurant
(1015 review)
Fifi's on the Beach Seafood Restaurant
  • 6934 Collins Ave, Miami Beach, FL 33141, United States
Seafood restaurant
+1 305-865-5665
BiB Noodle Bar
(212 review)
BiB Noodle Bar
  • Unit 13D, FarGo Village, Far Gosford St, Coventry CV1 5ED, United Kingdom
Chinese noodle restaurant
+44 7498 956496
Angel Bar & Supper Club - Caversham - Reading
(211 review)
Angel Bar & Supper Club - Caversham - Reading
  • 18 Prospect St, Reading RG4 8JG, United Kingdom
restaurant
+44 118 229 5042
The Grind Bistro
(137 review)
The Grind Bistro
  • 96 Knights Hill, Norwood, London SE27 0JL, United Kingdom
Cafe
+44 20 8761 9044